LIVE: UMPHREY’S MCGEE – St. Augustine, FL, USA – August 31, 2025

Venue: St. Augustine Amphitheater

City: St. Augustine, FL

Date: August 31, 2025

Review and Photographs by: Jason Beutel

Even heavy Florida rain couldn’t dampen the spirit when Umphrey’s McGee rolled into St. Augustine for a late-summer performance at the Backyard Stage of the Saint Augustine Amphitheatre. Known affectionately as The Amp, the venue has earned its reputation as one of the Southeast’s premier mid-sized amphitheatres — its mix of intimate sightlines, coastal humidity, and a crowd that reliably shows up rain or shine — makes for memorable nights. Sunday was no exception. The weather set the tone early. As fans made their way into town, crossing the iconic Bridge of Lions, whitecaps could be seen rolling across Matanzas Bay—a sure sign the storm was only gaining strength. By the time concertgoers gathered inside The Amp, the skies opened up. Instead of retreating, the crowd embraced it—ponchos rustled, beers were hoisted defiantly, and a communal grin spread through the sea of wet concertgoers.

When the band finally took the stage, the storm was still in play. But just a few songs in, the rain abated—almost as if the band had ordered it away. From there, Umphrey’s McGee settled into a marathon three-hour, two-set performance that underscored why they remain one of the most vital live acts on the touring circuit. The opening salvo—“Women Wine and Song” flowing directly into “2×2”—set the tone, a blend of technical precision and exploratory improvisation. From there, the first set leaned into fan favorites like “No Diablo” and a sprawling “Bridgeless,” with “Staircase” and “Professor Wormbog” showcasing the band’s seamless transitions. Despite the weather, or perhaps because of it, the interplay between Brendan Bayliss’ guitar lines and Joel Cummins’ keys felt sharper, more defiant, as if the band was intent on proving that the storm was merely another element in the show.

By the time set two began, the mist left behind by the storm had transformed into atmosphere, catching the band’s signature light rig. The effect was cinematic—beams of color slicing through fog, enveloping the Backyard Stage in a glow that felt both ethereal and electric. Highlights included the unexpected cover of Night Ranger’s “Sister Christian,” which morphed into a heavy-hitting “Puppet String.” The centerpiece sequence—“The Triple Wide” → “Corduroy” → “Higgins”—delivered on the band’s reputation for adventurous segues, stretching grooves into psychedelic terrain before snapping back into tightly composed passages. The encore, a fiery “Cut the Cable,” capped the evening with urgency and punch, sending the soaked but elated crowd back into the St. Augustine night. What makes a show like this remarkable isn’t just the setlist or the musicianship—though both were top-notch—but the shared resilience of band and audience. At The Amp’s Backyard Stage, framed by swaying palms and cleansed by summer rain, Umphrey’s McGee reaffirmed that live music is as much about atmosphere as execution. On August 31, 2025, they delivered both in abundance.

Setlist: Women Wine and Song – 2 x 2 – No Diablo – Staircase – Professor Wormbog – Bridgeless – Sister Christian – Puppet String – The Triple Wide – Corduroy – Higgins – Preamble – Mantis – Cut the Cable

[Show as slideshow]

UMPHREY’S MCGEE LINKS:

OFFICIAL SITE

FACEBOOK

X – TWITTER

INSTAGRAM

TOUR DATES

Category: Live Reviews, Photo Galleries